FIXING UP ALL-STAR CARDS: 1985 ROD CAREW

Once again, time to "fix" Topps' All-Star cards for Rod Carew, who was left out for the second year in a row in favor of a non-starter, this time the 1985 set:

Carew was once again selected by fans to start the Midsummer Classic in 1984, yet Topps decided to go with Eddie Murray once again, as they did in the 1984 set.

Carew was STILL an automatic at that slot for years at the time, and was the starter yet again in 1984.

The man was a player for the ages, as he would go on to play in 18 All-Star games, missing only his final season in the Majors in 1985. Just incredible.

The first nine seasons of his career were as an All-Star second baseman, while the last nine were as a first baseman.

The legend topped .300 15 years in a row, with a high of .388 in 1977 on his way to a Most Valuable Player Award and capturing the public’s attention with his .400 chase late in the season.
A clear-cut Hall of Fame player, he was inducted on his first year of eligibility in 1991 when he garnered 90.5% of the vote, which leaves me with the question: who the hell are the 9.5% who DIDN’T vote for him!!!???

3053 hits, a .328 career average, 353 stolen bases and 15 straight seasons of .300+ batting.

The man was a hitting machine, and I'm so glad I got to see him play during his magnificent career!

FIXING UP ALL-STAR CARDS: 1985 DAVE STIEB

Seriously! Has there been a player from this era that was more "shafted" than Dave Stieb?

Topps did him wrong yet again by leaving him out of the "All-Star" mix, even though he was the starting pitcher for the American League for the second straight year.

So today we go and give him his rightful All-Star card in the 1985 set:

 

He was such a work-horse in the 1980s!

Stieb would lead the A.L. in WAR three seasons in a row from 1982-1984, and would make seven All-Star teams, while getting Cy Young attention four times.

He would post 15+ wins six times, with a high of 18 in 1990, when he finally spun a no-hitter after a few near-misses in the ninth-inning.

By the time he retired he finished with a record of 176-137 over 443 games, with 30 shutouts and 1669 strikeouts, completing 103 of this starts.

I dreaded any time Stieb was starting against the Yankees, as he seemed to have their number every single time.

Such a great pitcher any team would have been lucky to have on their roster!

 

FIXING UP ALL-STAR CARDS: 1984 DAVE STIEB

On the blog today, "fixing" an All-Star snub for a guy who was snubbed more than once by the fine people at Topps, Dave Stieb, who started the 1983 Midsummer Classic for the American League but didn't get an All-Star card the following year:

Stieb was such a work-horse in the 1980s!

He was also the starter the following year for the A.L. and again, Topps didn't give him an All-Star card in the 1985 set!

Stieb would lead the A.L. in WAR three seasons in a row from 1982-1984, and would make seven All-Star teams, while getting Cy Young attention four times.

He would post 15+ wins six times, with a high of 18 in 1990, when he finally spun a no-hitter after a few near-misses.

By the time he retired he finished with a record of 176-137 over 443 games, with 30 shutouts and 1669 strikeouts, completing 103 of this starts.

I dreaded any time Stieb was starting against the Yankees, as he seemed to have their number every single time.

Such a great pitcher any team would have been lucky to have on their roster!

 

FIXING UP ALL-STAR CARDS: 1984 FRED LYNN

On the blog today, a real travesty for Topps regarding their All-Star cards of the 1980s.

Imagine being selected as a starter for your league, and THEN you go on to hit the FIRST grand slam in All-Star game history, helping your league win its first Midsummer Classic in 12 years, and you get OVERLOOKED for an All-Star card the following year!?

Well, welcome to California Angels star Fred Lynn, who had this very thing happen in 1984 when the new Topps baseball cards came out.

So here is his rightful All-Star card, 42 years later:

As for Mr. Lynn, after a wonderful college career at USC, Lynn became an instant star in 1975 when he led the Boston Red Sox to the World Series after copping both the Rookie of the Year AND Most Valuable Player Awards. The first player ever to do so, and still only one of two (Ichiro Suzuki joined him in 2001).
He’d go on to win four Gold Gloves, get named to nine all-star teams, and hit the only Grand Slam in All-Star game history, a memorable shot off of Atlee Hammaker in the 1983 classic that gave the American League it’s first win over the National League since 1971.
Hampered by injuries throughout his 17-year career, he still finished with a very solid MLB resume: 306 homers, 1111 RBI’s, 1063 runs scored and a .283 batting average, with 10 seasons of 20+ homers over 1969 games.

 

FIXING UP ALL-STAR CARDS: 1984 ROBIN YOUNT

Up on the blog today we have another 1980s Topps All-Star fix, this time a 1984 All-Star card for the 1983 American League starting shortstop, Robin Yount:

If you remember, Topps decided to give Cal Ripken the All-Star card in their 1984 set over the rightful player, Yount. Still a mystery as to why Topps changed their All-Star card selection process in 1981. Never a fan of that!

Yount went 0-2 at the plate with a run scored and an RBI in the 1983 Midsummer Classic, the first win for the A.L. since 1971! I remember that game vividly, as I watched it as a 14-year-old and witnessing an A.L. win for the very first time as a young baseball fan.

A Milwaukee Brewer for life, Yount finished his great career with 3142 hits, 1632 runs scored, 251 homers and 271 stolen bases, taking home two A.L. MVP Awards and incredibly only making three All-Star teams. How on earth?!
Anyway, it’s amazing to realize that when he had his first true All-Star season in 1980, after what was already seven years in the Big Leagues, Yount was STILL only 24 years of age!
He was on cruise-control from then on, elevating his game to become one of the elite players in the American League, with 1982 the high point when he led the Brewers to the World Series and taking home his first MVP Award.
What a player...

 

FIXING UP ALL-STAR CARDS: 1984 MANNY TRILLO

Today on the blog we fix another 1980's Topps All-Star snub, this time a 1984 card for Manny Trillo of the Cleveland Indians, the starter at second base for the American league in the 1983 game:

Topps decided to give the All-Star card to Lou Whitaker of the Detroit Tigers, a practice that I came to hate as a kid collecting back then. Why stray from the voted players? 

Anyway, Trillo would find himself shipped off to the Montreal Expos after the All-Star game, before ending up with the San Francisco Giants for the 1984 season.

He’d put together an excellent career that saw him win a World Championship with the Philadelphia Phillies in 1980, win three Gold Gloves between 1979 and 1983 and get tabbed for four All-Star games.
By the time he retired after the 1989 season he finished up with 1562 hits over 5950 at-bats, good for a .263 average, with 598 runs scored and 571 runs batted in.

 

FIXING UP ALL-STAR CARDS: 1984 ROD CAREW

Up on the blog today, we go ahead and "fix up" another 1980s Topps All-Star card, this time giving Rod Carew his rightful 1984 All-Star card as the American League's starting first baseman for the 1983 game:

Topps inexplicably went and gave Baltimore Orioles legend Eddie Murray the All-Star card, but why!?

Carew was still an automatic at that slot for years at the time, and was the starter yet again in 1983 when the A.L. FINALLY won after a 12-year losing streak.

The man was a player for the ages, as he would go on to play in 18 All-Star games, missing only his final season in the Majors in 1985. Just incredible.

The first nine seasons of his career were as an All-Star second baseman, while the last nine were as a first baseman.

The legend topped .300 15 years in a row, with a high of .388 in 1977 on his way to a Most Valuable Player Award and capturing the public’s attention with his .400 chase late in the season.
A clear-cut Hall of Fame player, he was inducted on his first year of eligibility in 1991 when he garnered 90.5% of the vote, which leaves me with the question: who the hell are the 9.5% who DIDN’T vote for him!!!???

3053 hits, a .328 career average, 353 stolen bases and 15 straight seasons of .300+ batting.

The man was a hitting machine, and I'm so glad I got to see him play during his magnificent career!

FIXING UP ALL-STAR CARDS: 1984 STEVE SAX

The next All-Star "fix" on the blog will be the one for Los Angeles Dodgers second baseman Steve Sax in the 1984 set, since he was elected as starter for the 1983 game:

The guy who was given an All-Star card in that set turned out to be Pittsburgh Pirates second baseman Johnny Ray, who certainly was not a horrible choice.

However, why Topps moved away from just showing the Midsummer Classic starters beginning in 1981 is beyond me, and I always hated it.

Sax was a solid player throughout his somewhat brief career, coming up with the Dodgers for a handful of games in 1981 before putting in his first full year in 1982, leading to a National League Rookie of the Year Award based off his .282 hitting with 59 stolen bases, 88 runs scored and 180 hits.

I enjoyed his time at the end of the decade with the New York Yankees, where he played three years between 1989 and 1991, posting a 200-hit season while just missing out on a second in '91 when he totaled 198.

His 1986 was arguably his best when he collected career-highs in hits (210), doubles (43), OBP (.390) and SLG (.441).

By the time he retired after the 1994 season, he finished with 1949 hits over 1769 games, hitting .281 with 913 runs scored and 444 stolen bases. 

Not a bad career at all.

FIXING UP ALL-STAR CARDS: 1984 AL OLIVER

The next 1980's "All-Star Card Fix" is a 1984 card for Al Oliver, who was the starting first baseman for the National League in the 1983 game, though George Hendrick of the St. Louis Cardinals got the card instead by Topps (???):

Again, why Topps decided to just go and select who THEY wanted to get an All-Star card starting in 1981 is beyond me.

Oliver was at the top of his game in the early-80s, and his two seasons with the Montreal Expos were fantastic, including leading the N.L. in doubles both years, while also taking home the batting title in 1982 along with most hits (204) and most RBIs (109).

What do you call a guy who was a seven-time all-star, Silver Slugger winner at three different positions, collector of over 2700 hits, 200 home runs, .300 career average, 1300 runs batted in, and 500 doubles?

I call that a Hall of Famer, especially when you consider that the first nine years or so of his career were the "dead" 1970's.

Yes I know an argument can be made here for Oliver's Hall-worthiness.

But I have always felt that he fell into that Vada Pinson, Dave Parker, Steve Garvey crowd that should have gotten, at the very LEAST, more of a shot at Cooperstown.

I mean, when he was finally eligible for Hall voting, he only got 4.3% and was dropped just like that! THAT is just insane.

He won three consecutive Silver Slugger Awards in 1980-1982, as an outfielder, a designated hitter and a first baseman and he batted .300 or better eleven times in his 18-year career!

He finished in the top-10 in batting eight times during his career, in the top-10 in hits eight times in his career, top-10 in doubles nine times in his career, top-10 in total bases five times, runs scored four times, runs batted in four times, triples three times, extra base hits five times and slugging percentage twice.

Is THAT enough of a statement? His consistency was amazing.

And to top it off, he should have been the National League Rookie of the Year in 1969 but got ripped off, with the award going to Los Angeles Dodger Ted Sizemore.

Al Oliver is grossly overlooked as far as players of that era in my book.

FIXING UP ALL-STAR CARDS: 1984 MARIO SOTO

Today on the blog we go ahead and "fix" another All-Star card snub, this time a 1984 All-Star card for the National League starter for the 1983 game, Mario Soto of the Cincinnati Reds:

1984 is really where Topps went off the rails with their All-Star cards, pretty much just ignoring the starters of the Midsummer Classic and just giving the honor to whomever they wanted.

There's NO better example than ignoring the pitcher who started the game in 1983 for the N.L., Mario Soto, ace of the Reds.

Soto started the game, tossing two innings and taking the rare loss for the N.L., though he only gave up two unearned runs in that game before the American League blew it open later on, capped off with the Fred Lynn grand slam off Atlee Hammaker.

Soto would go on to have an excellent 1983 season, finishing runner-up for the Cy Young Award with a record of 17-13, with a 2.70 ERA and 242 strikeouts, with three shutouts along the way.

An absolute stud on the mound between 1980 and 1985, he'd strikeout as many as 274 batters (1982) while averaging 14 wins a season before arm troubles did him in by the age of 30.

He'd retire at only 33 after the 1988 season with 100 wins and a 3.47 ERA over 297 appearances, with 13 shutouts over 72 complete games, striking out 1449 along the way.

 

FIXING UP ALL-STAR CARDS: 1981 JIM RICE

Today we'll really begin a fun thread that will take us into 2026, fixing up All-Star cards that Topps either messed up or just disregarded outright during the 1980s, beginning with the "Missing" 1981 A.L. outfielder, Jim Rice:

If you were a kid like me collecting then, you were immediately frustrated with the All-Star cards that were pulled out of the packs, especially when the National League starter for 1980, J.R. Richard, wasn't given the All-Star banner in lieu of Steve Carlton and Jim Bibby. Huh???

Breaking with tradition, Topps started giving All-Star cards/banners to players not necessarily voted by the fans like they always did.

In the case of Jim Rice, he was indeed voted as a starter for the 1980 game, and though he wouldn't play due to injury and was replaced by Ben Oglivie, neither of them were given the All-Star banner, with the A.L. missing a third outfielder to go with Reggie Jackson and Fred Lynn!

That killed me, especially coming off 1978 with Richie Zisk and 1979 with Freddie Patek also being denied card immortality.

Moving forward I also hope to give All-Star cards to players that were actually voted to start through the decade, as opposed to some really odd Topps picks for All-Star cards.

Keep an eye out for that!